Should Your Online Persona Be Different From Your Offline?

“What if my personality in real life is different from my online one?” I was once asked during an interview. “Do I need to hide who I truly am online so people will want to connect with me and I can find a job?”


My answer:
If you need to hide who you truly are just so people will connect with you, then you need to reexamine your life. If you have an abrasive personality, tell wildly inappropriate jokes, or are a jerk in real life, then you don’t need to hide who you are, you need to change.

Hide or change?

I’ll admit it’s a pretty harsh answer, but it’s true. Otherwise the implication is that the other person is not going to be nice, unless a job or valuable opportunity is at stake. “Well, I was going to be an a-hole, but you work for a company I want to work for, so I’m going to be nice to you. For now.”

That’s not how social media and personal branding works. Since when did being nice become optional? Since when is jerkiness the default position, and niceness is the fallback?

Get a glimpse into who someone really is

The thing I like about social media is that, for the most part, you can see who everyone is. It’s not like the comments section of most major newspapers, which have become cesspools of racist and homophobic language. The trolls who live there hide behind the anonymity of the Internet; while social media lets others see who you are.

That’s why some newspapers are having people log in with Facebook instead. If people are forced to use their real name and real photo, they’re less likely to spew their venom on others. If a face and name can be linked directly to jerky behavior, those people are less likely to be jerks.

Maybe I’m being overly optimistic and Pollyannaish, but I don’t think you should have to choose between behaving appropriately and being a jerk. I’d like to think that people are generally good people, and that they’ll treat other people with respect. But if you find that you have to make a choice just to get a job or grow your network, you need to look at what your “changing from” starting point is. If you find that person is not someone other people want to hire, connect with, or friend, figure out who you want to be instead. Then be that person.

Author:

Erik Deckers is the co-owner and VP of Creative Services for Professional Blog Service in Indianapolis. Erik co-authored Branding Yourself: Using Social Media to Invent or Reinvent Yourself, and is working on a new social media book. Erik frequently speaks about blogging and social media for personal branding and small business marketing.

Picture of Erik Deckers

Erik Deckers

is the owner of Professional Blog Service, a newspaper humor columnist, and the co-author of Branding Yourself: How to Use Social Media to Invent or Reinvent Yourself, No Bullshit Social Media: The All-Business, No-Hype Guide to Social Media Marketing, and The Owned Media Doctrine.

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

Neuroscientists studying silence found that noise degrades the brain in ways writers have always felt but never had a word for — and the mechanism is more specific than anyone expected

Neuroscientists studying silence found that noise degrades the brain in ways writers have always felt but never had a word for — and the mechanism is more specific than anyone expected

The Blog Herald

53% of Gen Z say becoming a creator is a viable career and the industry that used to mock that idea is now paying attention

53% of Gen Z say becoming a creator is a viable career and the industry that used to mock that idea is now paying attention

The Blog Herald

A 16-year study of 373 couples found whether they fought in year one made no difference to whether they divorced. What predicted it was something researchers had to watch very carefully to see.

A 16-year study of 373 couples found whether they fought in year one made no difference to whether they divorced. What predicted it was something researchers had to watch very carefully to see.

The Vessel

Edison Research finds podcasts now reach 58% of Americans monthly — which helps explain why Vox’s podcast network was worth acquiring at all

Edison Research finds podcasts now reach 58% of Americans monthly — which helps explain why Vox’s podcast network was worth acquiring at all

The Blog Herald

Yes, AI might be useful in mental health. No, that still doesn’t make it therapy

Yes, AI might be useful in mental health. No, that still doesn’t make it therapy

The Vessel

There is a kind of blog with 500 readers that has more actual influence than one with 500,000 and the difference has nothing to do with content quality

There is a kind of blog with 500 readers that has more actual influence than one with 500,000 and the difference has nothing to do with content quality

The Blog Herald